Barbara Brunelle

I strongly oppose HB 1313-FN, which repeals buffer zones for reproductive health care facilities. Buffer zones exist to protect patients, health care providers, and staff from harassment, intimidation, and potential violence while accessing or providing lawful medical care. Journalistic reporting from clinics without implemented buffer zones describes patients and staff being regularly harangued by protestors, called names like “murderers” or “baby killers,” followed home, or blocked while entering the facility. Protesters have also used graphic images and misinformation targeting patients. City buffer zone (20-foot) laws like the one in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania were passed after documented harassment including protesters pounding on clinic windows, following staff, and photographing patients without consent. The 2012 ordinance was enacted to stop protesters from crowding, shouting at, and blocking the entrances and driveways of health clinics. The Supreme Court has declined to hear challenges against it, leaving it in place as a valid safety measure. Research from the National Clinic Violence 2022 Survey shows clinics without buffer zones reported less reduction in death threats, invasions, and blockades compared to clinics with buffer zones — suggesting buffer areas help reduce serious negative incidents. Repealing these protections would undermine public safety, discourage people from seeking necessary health services, and place an unfair burden on individuals during highly personal and often stressful moments. The right to free speech does not include the right to harass or obstruct others. I urge the committee to reject HB 1313-FN and uphold reasonable safeguards that protect access to reproductive health care and ensure safety for all.