Georgina Lambert

Testimony Against New Hampshire HB 1372 I stand in strong opposition to New Hampshire House Bill 1372. While the intention behind this bill—to establish a commission to study the feasibility of reestablishing a state psychiatric hospital for adults with severe mental illness—may appear noble, the history and implications of such a move are fraught with danger and potential harm to those we aim to assist. Historical Context: Laconia State School The Laconia State School, once a beacon of mental health care in New Hampshire, serves as a cautionary tale in our approach to psychiatric facilities. Founded in the early 20th century, it was intended to provide specialized care for individuals with developmental disabilities and mental illness. However, over time, it became a place where patients faced neglect, abuse, and systemic failures. The closure of Laconia State School in 1991 highlighted the urgent need to shift from institutionalized care to community-based services. This shift was pivotal in embracing a more humane approach to mental health, which recognizes the dignity and autonomy of individuals. Unfortunately, HB 1372 threatens to reverse this progress by considering a return to a model that has proven damaging to vulnerable populations. Risks of Reestablishing State Psychiatric Hospitals 1. Stigmatization of Mental Illness Reopening a state psychiatric hospital could reinforce negative stereotypes about mental illness. It risks perpetuating the image of mental health patients as dangerous or incapable of integration into society. We must prioritize initiatives that foster understanding, rather than those that isolate individuals within institutional walls. 2. Reinforcement of Inadequate Care Models Establishing a commission to reopen a psychiatric hospital may divert attention and resources away from improving community-based mental health services. Community care allows for tailored, inclusive, and dignified support, fostering recovery in a way that institutions often cannot. 3. Ignoring Current Trends and Needs Current data show a need for better mental health crisis intervention, prevention, and rehabilitation services rather than a return to outdated institutionalized models. A focus on blanket institutional solutions disregards the complexities of mental health needs today. Conclusion The proposed bill gives little consideration to the lessons learned from the history of poorly managed psychiatric institutions such as the Laconia State School. We must resist the allure of establishing facilities that echo a past marked by neglect and suffering. Instead, let's invest in proven community-based mental health strategies that honor the dignity of those with mental illness and foster their integration into society. As you consider the implications of HB 1372, I urge you to reflect on our commitment to a more effective, compassionate, and modern approach to mental health care in New Hampshire. Thank you for your attention.