Senate Commerce Committee
Aaron Jones 271-2609
SB 165, relative to the audit requirements for consumer cooperative associations.
Hearing Date: February 20, 2025
Time Opened: 10:49 a.m. Time Closed: 11:05 a.m.
Members of the Committee Present: Senators Ricciardi, Murphy, McGough and Reardon
Members of the Committee Absent : Senators Innis and Fenton
Bill Analysis: This bill increases the threshold for an annual audit or review of a consumers' cooperative association's books.
Sponsors:
Sen. Avard | Sen. Murphy | Sen. Birdsell |
Sen. Rochefort | Sen. Lang | Sen. Gannon |
Sen. Innis | Sen. Reardon | Sen. Pearl |
Sen. McConkey | Sen. Watters | Rep. Kofalt |
________________________________________________________________________________
Who supports the bill: Senator Kevin Avard, Senator Howard Pearl, Senator William Gannon, Senator David Rochefort, Senator Mark McConkey, Abby Bronson (NH Community Loan Fund), Daniel Hotchkiss (Hodges Development Corporation), Maria Carlson (Hodges Development Corporation), Kim Capen (MOTA), Martha Dickey, Kevin Brigham, Nancy Lewis, Amanda Sanchez, Anthony Sanchez, Henry Ingham
Who opposes the bill: Daniel Richardson
Who is neutral on the bill: No one
Summary of testimony presented in support:
Senator Kevin Avard
- This bill would increase the threshold for annual audit reviews of consumer cooperative association books.
- Throughout New Hampshire, there are 151 resident owned communities. They allow residents to own their homes at a lower cost compared to similar sized homes or renting.
- These communities operate without state government subsidies.
- Auditing can cost up to $10,000 resulting in lot rent increases for individual homeowners. Often, it is also difficult to find accountants that audit revenues over $250,000.
- This bill would align resident owned communities with non-profits by raising the revenue threshold for required audits from $250,000 to $2 million. This would ensure smaller communities are not forced to conduct costly audits that do not improve their financial transparency or accountability.
- For organizations with $1 million or less in revenue, at least 3 elected association members would conduct an internal financial audit and report it back to the full association.
- If they have revenues between $1 and $2 million, they can conduct a formal financial review to maintain transparency, while also reducing costs. Financial reviews completed by outside accounting firms cost at least half of what a traditional audit would cost.
- For organizations with $2 million in revenue, they would be required to ensure appropriate financial oversight.
- This bill took a balanced approach to strengthen resident owned communities by eliminating financial burdens, preserving transparency and accountability, and helping to sustain and expand residential ownership by removing barriers.
Abby Bronson, Director of Policy and Advocacy, New Hampshire Community Loan Fund
- New Hampshire Community Loan Fund has helped to secure homeownership for 9,000 families in 151 communities.
- This bill would update auditing requirements for consumer cooperatives, which is in line with current auditing thresholds for non-profits.
- The average resident owned community has 60 homes. When the auditing requirements were placed into law, it was expected that communities above this average would have to conduct financial audits. As a result of their size, the cost was better distributed among households.
- Due to increased costs, however, smaller parks are subject to auditing requirements. Recently, they worked with a resident owned community with 33 homes that must do an annual audit. If it costs $10,000 for an audit, it would be an extra $300 per home in annual costs.
- Given the housing market, Ms. Bronson said any increase should be looked at closely. In the case of smaller communities, audits placed an unnecessary burden on them.
- While formal financial reviews are less costly, they have similar safeguards.
- Manufactured housing is one of the few affordable homeownership options available.
- Senator McGough asked when the last time audit requirements were adjusted.
- Ms. Bronson replied 35 years ago.
Daniel Hotchkiss, Chief Financial Officer, Hodges Development Corporation
- Resident owned communities are a key component of the housing community because they offer affordable homeownership opportunities to families.
- Often, these communities must deal with infrastructure needs that were deferred by previous owners, including the repair or replacement of water and sewer systems as well as roadways.
- Communities have little control over costs, particularly utilities, real estate taxes, and city water and sewer.
- Mr. Hotchkiss said lot increases have a negative impact on owners and their personal budgets. Audits can cost between $8,500 and $10,000 annually, and in conjunction with other costs, rents can increase up to $100.
- Cooperative boards must balance the needs of their membership, many who live on fixed incomes, with escalating costs and improvements.
- Mr. Hotchkiss said a resident owned community with $250,000 in gross revenues is equivalent to 60 homes paying $347.25 in lot rent. If it is assumed the cost of an audit is $9,500, and a review cost $5,000, it would increase total annual costs by $4,500. This would result in a $6.25 monthly increase just in audit costs.
- Mr. Hotchkiss said the increased audit threshold would help communities move forward and spend their money where it is needed.
Kim Capen, New Hampshire Manufactured Homeowners and Tenants Association
- The Legislature should make it easy for these affordable homeownership options to thrive.
- This bill would alleviate the financial and logistical burden posed on resident owned communities by current auditing thresholds.
- Mr. Capen said they keep costs as low as possible to ensure monthly lot rents are affordable.
- Financial accountability is important, and this bill would approve alternative examination methods. Specifically, communities above $1 million could still use certified professional accountants.
Summary of testimony presented in opposition: None
Neutral Information Presented: None
AJ
Date Hearing Report completed: February 27, 2025